waterfiltertested
Buying guide

Home Water Test Kits: Strips vs Mail-In Lab Tests

Short answerTest strips are a rough screen. For private wells, suspected lead pipes, PFAS or flood recovery, use a state-certified lab, and for PFAS ask for EPA Method 533 or 537.1 with a reporting limit at or below the limit you want to compare.

By Steffen Hartmann · Last updated

Choosing a test starts with the question you need answered. A quick look at hardness or chlorine can be done at home. Whether your well is safe, whether lead is in your tap, or whether PFAS is present needs a laboratory, and the lab has to be certified.

Key facts

  • EPA advises private well owners to test every year for total coliform bacteria, nitrates, total dissolved solids and pH (EPA, private wells page, updated 2026).
  • EPA says only laboratories certified for drinking water testing should be used, and that local health departments may test private wells for free (EPA, private wells page).
  • EPA Methods 533 and 537.1 together cover the 29 PFAS measured in UCMR 5 (EPA, UCMR 5 page, 2026).
  • EPA’s UCMR 5 minimum reporting levels for the 29 PFAS range from 2 to 20 ppt (EPA, UCMR 5 page, 2026).
  • EPA’s limits for PFOA and PFOS are 4.0 ppt each, as a running annual average, with water system compliance due by 2029 under the 2024 rule. In May 2026 EPA proposed letting systems request two more years, to 2031 (EPA PFAS rule page, 2026).
  • EPA says a lead test costs between $20 and $100 (EPA, lead page).
  • Lead is most likely in older cities and in homes built before 1986 (EPA, lead page).
  • Under EPA rules the lead action level is 0.015 mg/L, falling to 0.010 mg/L from November 1, 2027 (EPA NPDWR table).

Strips, mail-in kits and certified labs

Option How it works Good for Limits
Test strips You dip a strip and match the color to a chart A fast screen of items such as chlorine, hardness or pH Color matching is approximate. Not suited to PFAS, which are reported in parts per trillion
Mail-in lab kit You fill supplied bottles and ship them to a lab Lead, metals, nitrate, bacteria, sometimes PFAS Check which lab runs it and which methods it is certified for
Certified lab, direct You or a technician collect the sample for a state-certified lab Private wells, disputes, post-flood checks You arrange it yourself. Prices vary by analyte
Health department Local service, sometimes free Bacteria and nitrate in private wells Limited list of tests

EPA says laboratories sometimes send a trained technician to collect the sample, and that you may obtain better samples and more reliable results that way.

How to find a certified lab

EPA lists contact information for state certification programs and their certified drinking water laboratories. NSF suggests searching with the keywords “accredited” and “water”, and notes that accredited labs are not typically tied to a filter manufacturer.

That independence matters when the result decides what you buy or whether you drink the water.

When you need a test

Private wells

If your drinking water does not come from a public water system, EPA states you alone are responsible for making sure it is safe. Public systems are tested and reported on; private wells are not. Test annually, and again when:

  • there are known problems in your area’s groundwater,
  • conditions near the well change, such as flooding, land disturbance or construction,
  • you replace or repair any part of the well system,
  • you notice a change in odor, color or taste.

EPA also lists nearby activities that point to specific tests, such as farming (nitrate, pesticides, bacteria), gas stations (VOCs) and mining (metals).

Old pipes and lead

Lead dissolves from lead pipes, solder and brass fixtures. Your utility’s system-wide results do not describe your own faucet, according to EPA. Testing is the only sure way to know.

For lead and copper, NSF notes a common instruction is a “first draw” sample: let the water sit overnight, then fill the bottle from the kitchen tap before running any water. Follow your lab’s written instructions, since collection steps differ by test.

After a flood

CDC warns that floodwater can carry infectious disease and chemical hazards. For a private well, EPA advises you to:

  1. stay away from the pump while it is flooded,
  2. not drink or wash with water from the flooded well,
  3. have a well or pump contractor clean and disinfect the well before turning on the pump,
  4. run the pump until the water is clear,
  5. ask your county or state health department about testing if it does not clear.

PFAS

If you are on a public system, start with EPA’s UCMR 5 results for your supplier and your supplier’s annual water quality report. A private well is not covered by UCMR 5, so testing is the only way to get a number.

PFAS testing: what to ask the lab

Two EPA drinking water methods exist for PFAS: Method 533 and Method 537.1. Method 533 is a solid phase extraction liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry method. The UCMR 5 program covered all 29 PFAS within the scope of the two methods.

Ask the lab:

  • Which method do you use, 533, 537.1 or both?
  • Which PFAS do you report?
  • What is your reporting limit for PFOA and PFOS?

The reporting limit is the lowest value the lab can report. To compare a result with EPA’s 4.0 ppt limits, you need a lab whose reporting limit is at or below that figure. Our own rule is that a result of “not detected” only means below the lab’s reporting limit, not zero.

Reading results against EPA limits

Results come in different units. Know the conversion:

  • mg/L equals parts per million (ppm).
  • µg/L equals parts per billion (ppb).
  • ng/L equals parts per trillion (ppt).
  • To convert µg/L to ng/L, multiply by 1,000 (EPA).
Contaminant EPA limit Notes
PFOA 4.0 ppt Maximum contaminant level, running annual average
PFOS 4.0 ppt Maximum contaminant level, running annual average
Arsenic 0.010 mg/L Maximum contaminant level
Nitrate (as nitrogen) 10 mg/L Maximum contaminant level
Nitrite (as nitrogen) 1 mg/L Maximum contaminant level
Lead 0.015 mg/L Action level, 0.010 mg/L from Nov. 1, 2027
Total coliform Goal of zero Any positive in a private well is a reason to call your health department

Three cautions:

  1. These limits are written for public systems. EPA presents them to private well owners as a reference. A single well sample is not an annual average.
  2. One result is a snapshot. If a result is above a limit, EPA advises contacting your health department and re-testing to confirm.
  3. Below the limit is not the same as absent. Report the number you receive and keep it. EPA notes that regular testing builds a record of water quality that helps solve later problems.

After the result

Match any treatment to the specific contaminant. Filters carry claims per contaminant, so see our pitcher guide for how to read a certificate. If bacteria turn up in a well, filters are not the first step. EPA says high bacteria can sometimes be controlled by disinfecting the well, and that you may need a new water source depending on the contaminant.

We earn commission on some links on this site. Ratings and certificate checks are never for sale. See how we test.

Questions people ask

Are water test strips accurate enough?

Strips read by color match and suit a quick screen. They are not a substitute for a certified lab when a result decides whether you drink the water, treat a well or buy a filter. EPA advises using laboratories certified for drinking water testing.

How often should I test a private well?

EPA advises testing every year for total coliform bacteria, nitrates, total dissolved solids and pH. Test sooner if there is flooding, new construction nearby, repairs to the well system, or a change in taste, odor or color.

Which EPA methods test for PFAS in drinking water?

EPA Methods 533 and 537.1. Together they cover the 29 PFAS that were measured in EPA's UCMR 5 program. Ask the lab which method it uses and which PFAS it reports.

What do I do after a flood if I have a well?

EPA advises staying away from the pump while it is flooded, not drinking or washing with the water, and getting a well or pump contractor to clean and disinfect the well before you turn the pump on. Contact your health department about testing.

How do I know if my pipes contain lead?

EPA says testing is the only sure way to know if lead is in your tap water, because you cannot see, taste or smell it. Homes built before 1986 and homes with lead service lines are more likely to have a problem.

Does a result below the EPA limit mean my water is fine?

EPA limits are legal standards for public water systems and are averaged over time. A private well result is a snapshot. Use limits as a reference, repeat the test, and talk to your health department if a result is close to or above one.

Sources

  1. EPA: Protect Your Home's Water (private wells)
  2. EPA Home Water Testing Facts
  3. EPA: Basic Information about Lead in Drinking Water
  4. EPA: National Primary Drinking Water Regulations
  5. EPA: Fifth Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule (UCMR 5)
  6. EPA: Method 533 for PFAS in Drinking Water
  7. EPA: PFAS National Primary Drinking Water Regulation
  8. EPA: Certified Laboratories for Drinking Water
  9. NSF: Drinking Water Testing
  10. CDC: Floods and Your Safety